Bishop Gerardo Alminaza of San Carlos, president of Caritas Philippines, demanded an independent investigation into the arrests of protesters and journalists during the ASEAN Summit in Manila, warning that the crackdown threatened constitutional rights and press freedom.
In a November 19 statement issued from Antalya, Türkiye, Alminaza urged authorities to account for everyone arrested during the November 15 protests and investigate reported abuses against detainees.
The bishop welcomed the release of more than 200 people arrested in Muntinlupa, including all minors who had remained in custody, but said authorities must still answer questions about their treatment.
Nine protesters arrested at Liwasang Bonifacio remained detained at the Manila Police District as of November 19, according to Alminaza.
“We cannot welcome the release of some while forgetting those who remain behind bars,” he said.
The prelate condemned the arrest and detention of journalists covering the demonstrations, citing the constitutional guarantee of press freedom.
“Detaining journalists for carrying out legitimate reporting duties threatens that freedom and creates a chilling effect on others documenting public events and police operations,” he said.
He demanded that the Philippine National Police and other government agencies explain why journalists were arrested, who ordered their detention and the legal grounds for holding them.
“These arrests must be independently investigated, and those responsible for any violations must be held accountable. Journalists must never be punished for doing their work,” he said.
The bishop also raised concerns over findings by the Commission on Human Rights (CHR), whose investigators observed detainees with visible injuries and reported crowding and poor ventilation in a holding area.
He said CHR personnel were kept waiting for hours before entering Camp Bagong Diwa.
Alminaza urged police to preserve custody records, operational orders and available video recordings to establish how detainees were injured, who authorized the operations and why human rights investigators initially faced restrictions.
He cited a November 17 report by KAPATID documenting 306 arrests across Sucat, Liwasang Bonifacio and San Rafael, Bulacan. The group said the arrests raised its count of political prisoners from 551 to 857 at the time.
At a November 19 press conference at the University of the Philippines Student Union Building, National Union of Peoples’ Lawyers President Ephraim Cortez condemned the filing of what he described as fabricated charges against arrested protesters.
Speaking alongside Lakbayani delegates and leaders of progressive groups, Cortez said legal proceedings should not be used to intimidate or punish people for participating in demonstrations.
He maintained that protesting against poverty, corruption and government policies that burden ordinary citizens was not a crime.
Cortez said the Constitution guaranteed freedom of expression and peaceful assembly, and that the government had an obligation to protect those rights rather than suppress them through violence and mass arrests.
He called for the dismissal of all remaining charges against the protesters and accountability for those responsible for what he described as unlawful mass arrests.
Alminaza also supported KAPATID’s call to examine whether authorities complied with detention limits under Article 125 and whether detainees were pressured to sign waivers.
The bishop said Muntinlupa prosecutors had dismissed two complaints for insufficient evidence and referred three others for further investigation.
Speaking from the COP31 climate conference, Alminaza raised concerns about the arrests of people questioning development projects affecting their livelihoods and ancestral lands.
He urged officials to meet with farmers and Indigenous communities raising concerns about Pax Silica, disclose relevant plans and address their grievances.
“We cannot speak of meaningful participation while people fear arrest for raising concerns or journalists risk detention for reporting them,” he said.
“When the poor speak of their suffering, they must not be met with arrest and violence. They deserve to be heard, their grievances taken seriously, and their dignity respected,” he said.
Alminaza urged parishes and Church social action teams to assist affected families with legal support, medical care and other needs.
He thanked lawyers, human rights groups, people’s organizations and individuals who helped secure the detainees’ release.
“The government must account for every person arrested and answer to the families still waiting,” he said.








